Review of the basic methodology since the work by ashenfelter and card 1985, the use of difference in differences methods has become very widespread. Matched difference in differences is one example of combining methods. Propensity score matching, difference indifferences models, treatment evaluation. Single diff in diff, diff in diff controlling for covariates, kernelbased propensity score matching diff in diff, and the quantile diff in diff. The impact evaluation book has a section on mixed methods that gives a really good treatment of the power of using both psm and dd.
Dec 01, 2014 standard differenceindifferences designs. However, in many applications of this method, the treatment rate increases more only in the treatment group. Using propensity scores in differenceindifferences. Departments of sociology and statistics, indiana university 2016 stata conference from stata users group. Differencesindifferences estimation in r and stata a. Diff indiff controlling for covariates, kernelbased propensity score matching. Models 16 are random effects, fixed effects, first difference, random trend and slope, dynamic models with ma1 process, dynamic models with ar1 process. Matching is consistent if and only if selection is due to transitory shocks. I had searched and there are tones of answers related to each of those models, but together i havent been able to find them. In this article, i present the features of the userwritten command diff, which estimates difference indifferences did treatment effects.
However, if you have a multiple categorical variable, then i believe youd need to create dummies for use in pbalchk in any case, i cant really provide more guidance, since i not sure exactly what is going on given the limited information you provided. Simplifying the estimation of difference in differences treatment. The dd estimate is the quantity in the lower right hand box, which can be thought of either as the change in the difference between groups across time, or the change across time in the difference between. I need to know how can i combine in stata the did difference in difference model with the psm propensity score matching with crosssectional data. Difference in differences estimation in stata youtube. This often turns out to make a significant difference, and sometimes in surprising ways. Basics of did designs imagine that we have data from a treatment groups and a control group at the baseline and endline. When treatment assignment is correlated with preperiod trend only, the unmatched analysis is biased, and matching units on preperiod level or trend does not introduce additional bias. The regression approach dd sd1 sd0 b thus, under the weaker type i identification assumptions, the effect of the treatment on the treated att is given by the regression coefficient.
Combining difference in difference and matching for panel data analysis. Incorporating matching techniques to improve precision and reduce bias in did designs introducing tripledifferences designs. We thus strongly recommend switching from psmatch2 to teffects psmatch, and this article will help you make the transition. I am matching the names of two string from two different datasets.
This module should be installed from within stata by typing ssc install diff. In its basic version, a control group is untreated at two dates, whereas a treatment group becomes fully treated at the second date. Empirical researchers and graduate students alike will benefit from his clear explanations of the most widely used methods to analyze treatment effects, including difference in differences, matching, and regression discontinuity. Instead, it is correct to focus on the coefficient of the interaction term. However, given that the application of propensity scores in multiple treatment groups is new, factors affecting the performance of matching, stratification, and weighting in.
Examples include estimating the effects of a training program on job performance or the effects of a government program targeted at helping particular schools. From the abstract, it sounds they are using propensityscore matching and difference indifferences research designs, rather than a psmdid hybrid. Apr 11, 2018 reg is the typical regression command in stata that tells the program you are looking to linearly regress a dependent variable on other independent variables. Generalized difference in differences with panel data and. This article compared standard regression logistic, propensity score weighting, propensity score matching, and difference in difference did methods in determining the impact of secondgeneration antidepressant ad use on maniarelated visits among adult patients with bipolar disorder.
Difference indifferences combined with matching on pretreatment outcomes is a popular method for addressing nonparallel trends between a treatment and control group. Propensity score matching and, difference in differences cie training 1567. Combining di erenceindi erence and matching for panel data analysis weihua an departments of sociology and statistics indiana university. Stata does not have a built in command for propensity score matching, a nonexperimental method of sampling that produces a control group whose distribution of covariates is similar to that of the treated group. Abadies semiparametric differenceindifferences estimator. The options and the formulas are detailed for the single did, kernel propensity score did, quantile did and the balancing properties.
Nonparametric matching this python file implements a nonparametric matching estimator of eyx for binary y. Stata implementation of difference in differences with binary outcomes. An introduction to propensity score matching in stata. Jun 29, 2018 when treatment assignment is correlated with preperiod trend only, the unmatched analysis is biased, and matching units on preperiod level or trend does not introduce additional bias. A good difference in difference analysis involves matching of the control and treatment groups, so that they are very similar in every possible way, except receiving the treatment. Difference in difference, difference in differences,dd, did, did. Matching and regression to the mean in difference indifferences analysis. Difference in difference, difference indifferences,dd, did, did. Matching and regression to the mean in differencein. The estimation of causal effects by differenceindifference. We evaluate the impact of a city level intervention. The method option might become a bit messy, if we want to include matching and ipw options. Researchers should be aware of the threat of regression to the mean when constructing matched samples for difference.
It is fairly simple to implement and there are enough options to work with. Combining differenceindifference and matching for panel. Differences in differences animation beginner youtube. However, there are several userwritten modules for this method. Difference in differences did or dd is a statistical technique used in econometrics and quantitative research in the social sciences that attempts to mimic an experimental research design using observational study data, by studying the differential effect of a treatment on a treatment group versus a control group in a natural experiment. Differencesindifferences estimation in r and stata the tarzan. I would need to include the interaction terms ab ac bc and abc in the stata command for a ddd fe model, but not a and b. Using a large managed care claims database, a logistic regression was developed as a standard approach to. Can you state what is the econometric issue that requires both psm and did to remedy. Stata module to perform differences in differences estimation. Difference in differences sometimes difference indifferences, did, or dd is a technique used in econometrics that measures the effect of a treatment at a given period in time. Did estimation uses four data points to deduce the impact of a policy change or some other shock a. Using medicaid claims data from oregon, we systematically vary the distribution of two key. Difference indifferences with matching is a popular method to measure the impact of an intervention in health as well as social sciences.
Combining di erenceindi erence and matching for panel. Weihua an additional contact information weihua an. Differenceindifferences an overview sciencedirect topics. Single diffindiff, diffindiff controlling for covariates, kernelbased propensity score matching diffindiff, and the quantile diffindiff. Whats the difference between xtreg to reg in stata.
Sep 25, 2015 propensity score matching can identify treatment effects in a selection on observables context. The command is equipped with an attractive set of options. Propensity score matching can identify treatment effects in a selection on observables context. Diffindiff controlling for covariates, kernelbased propensity score matching. Simplifying the estimation of differenceindifferences. Simplifying the estimation of differenceindifferences treatment effects. Researchers employ two varieties of longitudinal data. A key difference between regression adjustment and matching or. Matched difference in differences statalist the stata forum. Stata module to perform differences in differences. The treatment effect, the cross difference, and the. Statalist stata implementation of differenceindifferences. An example of the features of diff is presented by using the dataset.
This paper explains the insights of the stata s user written command diff for the estimation of difference in differences treatment effects did. However, the quality of the matches can be affected by decisions made during the matching process, particularly the order in which subjects are selected for matching and the maximum permitted difference between matched subjects the caliper. Matching estimators are widely used in program evaluation matching estimators appeared in the 1990s in the literature on evaluating labor market programs in contrast to the techniques we have covered this term, it does not rely on natural experiments the basic idea originated and remains heavily used in medical studies. Matching, regression discontinuity, difference in differences. Propensity score matching is used when a group of subjects receive a treatment and wed like to compare their outcomes with the outcomes of a control group. An introduction to implementing difference in differences regressions in stata.
Pdf programme evaluation using difference in difference. If the condition does not hold in the pretreatment periods, then a modified dd takes the form of generalized difference in differences gdd, which is a triple difference td with one more timewise difference. Probably the simplest way to do that is to generate a matchgroup variable that identifies the matched pairs or triples or whatever. Selecting an appropriate caliper can be essential for. Evaluating the foreign ownership wage premium using a. The difference indifferences estimator measures the effect of a treatment or policy intervention by comparing change over time of the outcome variable across treatment groups. This lecture is part 9 of the propensity scores and related methods series presented and organized by robert greevy within vanderbilt universitys center for health services research. Stata does not have a builtin command for propensity score matching, a nonexperimental method of sampling that produces a control group whose distribution of covariates is similar to that of the treated group. The file generates graphs and datasets of selected quantile treatment effects on the treated, as well as several extensions proposed in my paper academic peer effects with different group. To interpret the estimate as a causal effect, this strategy requires that, in the absence of the treatment, the outcome variable followed the same trend in treated and untreated groups. The application of propensity score techniques matching, stratification, and weighting with multiple treatment levels are similar to those used in binary groups. However, previous simulations suggest that this approach does not always eliminate or reduce bias, and it is not clear when and why. I found some discussions of did methods in the statalist archive, such as this.
A natural way to check the condition is to backtrack one period and examine the response changes in two pretreatment periods. Run the following command in stata to load an example data set. In this paper, the statas command diff is explained and some details on its. A technique for program evaluation aradhna aggarwal department of business economics, south campus, university of delhi a free powerpoint ppt presentation displayed as a flash slide show on id. Difference in differences a single diffindiff b diffindiff. Running onetoone or onetomany matching using nearest neighbors with caliper.
On the use of twoway fixed effects regression models for. It is often used to measure the change induced by a particular treatment or event, though it may be subject to certain biases mean reversion bias, etc. Aug 01, 2016 the differenceindifference estimator or the double difference estimators is given by. Pdf a matching method with panel data researchgate. Differencesindifferences estimation in r and stata the. Another common justification for the use of the 2fe estimator is based on its equivalence to the difference indifferences estimator under the simplest setting with two groups and two time periods.
Matched difference indifferences is one example of combining methods. Differencesindifferences is a popular quasiexperimental methodology used to estimate causal effects from longitudinal observational data. Just found these very clear and pedagogical slides from the centre for research on impact evaluation europea commission dealing with propensity score matching psm and difference in differences did slides and for those using stata. Propensity score matching difference indifferences instrumental variables regression discontinuity today well focus on difference indifferences reminder on basic conceptstheory applications in stata learning objectives by the end of todays session, you should be able to. Propensity score and differenceindifference methods. Difference indifferences dd methods attempt to control for unobserved variables that bias estimates of causal effects, aided by longitudinal data collected from students, school, districts, or states. Difference in differences combined with matching on pretreatment outcomes is a popular method for addressing nonparallel trends between a treatment and control group. Nov 15, 2011 the estimation of causal effects by differenceindifference methods focuses on the case of only two differences although the basic ideas of differenceindifference did estimation could be extended to more than two dimensions to create differenceindifferenceindifferencein estimators.
There are no systematic differences between the treated and untreated groups that are related to the outcome of interest without random assignment i. The paper presents a modification of the matching and difference indifferences approach of heckman et al. Probably the simplest way to do that is to generate a match group variable that identifies the matched pairs or triples or whatever. Difference in differences, causal inference, kernel propensity score. Heckmans difference indifferences matching estimator 1 difference indifferences applies when each participant matches to multiple nonparticipants.
We are here to help, but wont do your homework or help you pirate software. In stata, how do i perform propensity score matching. Differencesindifferences evaluates the effect of a treatment. Jun 20, 2011 differences in differences estimation in r and stata a. Mar 02, 20 propensity score matching, difference in differences models, treatment evaluation in stata. The dd estimate is the quantity in the lower right hand box, which can be thought of either as the change in the difference between groups across time, or the change across time in the difference between groups. The coefficient for did is the differencesindifferences estimator.
Apr 01, 2018 an introduction to implementing difference in differences regressions in stata. Propensity score matching meets differenceindifferences. In its simplest form, the dd design can be illustrated in a 2. Running propensity score matching with statapsmatch2. Standardized difference estimates are increasingly used to describe to compare groups in clinical trials and observational studies, in preference over pvalues. Sep 29, 2016 just found these very clear and pedagogical slides from the centre for research on impact evaluation europea commission dealing with propensity score matching psm and difference in differences did slides and for those using stata, dont forget psmatch2 for psm and diff for did. You need to incorporate the matching into the analysis. Using propensity scores in differenceindifferences models. Github thomasgstewart propensityscorematchinginstata. Stata module for regression discontinuity estimation. We show that this equivalence does not hold under more general settings commonly encountered in applied research. Matching on the propensity score is widely used to estimate the effect of an exposure in observational studies. To demonstrate regression to the mean bias introduced by matching on preperiod variables in difference indifferences studies. In this article, i present the features of the userwritten command diff, which estimates difference in differences did treatment effects.
187 847 1114 519 358 1309 766 921 943 1654 239 393 1024 5 588 1541 46 1443 1011 1545 1376 430 796 731 695 1120 1636 253 988 1290 930 1045 1206 890 887 626 1367 1418 35 410 1000 1122 1474